• White Facebook Icon
  • White Instagram Icon

©2018 by Homespun.

DIY Whipped Body Butter

Updated: Jan 17, 2019

Body butter has to be the greatest thing since sliced bread. Seriously, before I had first learned to make body butter myself, I had only ever used lotion. That first time that I slathered on my own body butter concoction and felt just how soft and smooth it made my skin, I never wanted to go back. My skin has never felt softer, and happier with me than after I put on fresh homemade body butter. 

The best part is, this makes a really great holiday gift, and I plan on getting some done for gifts next year now that I've found a good recipe. Whether you scent it with essential oils or leave it plain with the nutty scent of the butters, everyone out there could use a good moisturizing body butter during the winter. You can put this butter into a really cute glass jar such as a mason jar, decorate it and fill all the stockings in the house with it! My favorite scents to wear would be lavender and pine, lavender and vanilla, and any sort of citrus combination that I can possibly come up with. (Though be careful about putting body butters with citrus oils in them and then going out to tan afterwards. Citrus oils can cause a sensitivity to sunlight, so be sure to use your butter AFTER you go tanning.)

Body Butter vs Lotion

The truth is, not only is it really easy to make, it is so much more moisturizing than lotion because it's not made with water. Being made with only oils and butters also means that there is no need to worry about preservatives either. Anything made with water needs a preservative to prevent bacteria from growing. Water also makes it where it sinks into the skin immediately so you get immediate moisture with a lotion but not an all day moisture. With body butter, the moisture is super healing to the skin because it keeps the skin hydrated for a much longer period of time.

The Secret to Smoothness

If you are using coconut oil and shea butter you may find that your body butter (or even your lip balms and salves) will turn a gritty consistency after melting and hardening again. This is totally normal and does not mean that it has gone bad. Simply melt your butter, cool it again over an ice bath, and re-whip it! This gritty consistency comes from crystals forming when it melted and hardened either too quickly or too slowly...usually the latter. This is also the reason I like to cool my body butter in an ice bath before whipping it. In some products such as lip balms and salves, simply use the product as is, there will be no difference in its healing and moisturizing capabilities.

DIY Moisturizing Whipped Body Butter


Combine the butters and coconut oil in a double boiler (or use a glass bowl over a pan of water) and melt. Once the mixture has completely melted. Remove from heat and pour into a bowl to cool quickly in an ice bath. (larger bowl underneath filled with ice and water to help the bowl above it cool quicker). In a separate smaller container, combine liquid oils, Vitamin E, and arrowroot powder. It is easiest to combine the arrowroot powder into the oil with a fork. When it looks like the butter is mostly firm, meaning there is still a small pool of liquid on top, pour in the liquid oil/arrowroot powder concoction and take out your electric hand mixer or emulsion blender. I usually use the whisk attachment on my electric hand mixer, blend until there are no chunks of hardened butter left. This cannot be done by hand. I usually take a spoon and chip away the bottom pieces first to make it easier to blend in the final result.If you added the liquid oils too soon and it is still not solid enough to pour into your containers, put the bowl of body butter mixture back into the ice bath for a minute or two more then blend it while therein sits in the ice bath. Spoon the butter into the containers that you plan to store the butter in.

If adding essential oils, this would be the point that you would add them into the butter. I like to add them into each container individually, so that I can personalize the scent, if I am giving them as gifts! I also prefer to do a different scent for myself than what I do for the girls. For the girls, I love to use Young Living SleepyIze or Gentle Baby essential oils, and use it as their before bed massage cream. It smells SO good, and it is relaxing for them. They drift right off to sleep!

Allow to sit overnight before use. The consistency of the butter will be more solidified into its true consistency, overnight.